Rome LLP

AllTariff Refunds Create a New Class of Commercial Disputes

Tariff Refunds Create a New Class of Commercial Disputes

Reading Time: 4 minutes

What Importers, Distributors, and Manufacturers Need To Know 

Nearly every company that imported goods in 2025 is currently grappling with the same question (and litigation exposure): who gets to keep the tariff refund? 

The Supreme Court struck down the IEEPA tariffs in February. Customs is sending the money back, but the importer of record is often not the party that bore the cost in the end and many importers billed the tariff to their customers as a surcharge, or built it into higher prices. Now those customers want their share.

Where the Tariff Refund Process Stands Now

The refund itself is moving quickly. In Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump, decided February 20, 2026, the Court held that IEEPA did not authorize the tariffs, and collection stopped four days later. U.S. Customs and Border Protection has since paid refunds in phases through its CAPE system, starting with unliquidated entries in April and reaching liquidated entries in October for importers that sued. As of October 2, CAPE had accepted about $136.6 billion in refund claims, and $126 billion had gone to the Treasury for payment. On October 8, the Court of International Trade certified a class of importers that had not filed their own suits, although that ruling can still be appealed.

What Creates Tariff Disputes and Can Consumers Get Tariff Refunds?

The structure of the refund is what creates the dispute. Customs pays the importer of record and no one else. A customer that paid a tariff surcharge has no claim against the government, and its only path to that money runs through the importer, and that means class actions. 

The Tariff Refund Lawsuits So Far: Customers Are Coming For Their Share

The first customer-led tariff refund class actions were filed against FedEx and UPS, which billed itemized duty charges, on the day of the Supreme Court’s decision. Suits followed against companies that raised prices more generally, including EssilorLuxottica, Costco, Lululemon, Nintendo and Campbell’s. Some complaints rely on executives’ own words. Case in point, the suit against EssilorLuxottica (Burgh v. EssilorLuxottica USA Inc., No. 1:26-cv-02786) points to earnings call remarks tying price increases to tariffs. Plaintiffs have asked to consolidate 25 retailer suits into a single proceeding, In re Retailer Tariff Litigation, MDL No. 3202. The legal theories vary, but the argument is the same: an importer that recovered the tariff from its customers should not be paid a second time by the government.

Consumer cases face an upstream battle. For example, Costco has argued that its customer got what he paid for and was never promised any part of the price back. A plaintiff also has to show how much of a price increase came from tariffs rather than freight, labor or demand. Many online terms require individual arbitration. As of the latest docket entry for Stockov v. Costco Wholesale Corp., No. 1:26-cv-02734, the court had not ruled on Costco’s motion to dismiss, even though Costco has now reported $184 million in refunds.

The Biggest Fights Are Between Businesses

A distributor or manufacturer that bought from an importer usually has what a consumer lacks when it comes to pursuing a tariff refund: 

  • A negotiated contract
  • Invoices showing the tariff charge
  • Enough money at stake to sue without a class 

These assets also apply to importers that bought from a supplier. IEEPA tariffs ran at least 10% on most goods and far higher on some. 

Will Tariff Refunds Be Issued? And to Whom?

Whether tariff refunds will be issued depends on a variety of factors. Three questions will decide most of these disputes: 

Question One: What does the contract say? 

An agreement that let the seller bill duties only as they came due reads very differently from a fixed price that left tariff risk with the seller. 

Question Two: What does the invoice show? 

A tariff billed as its own line or as a stated percentage is far easier to claim back than one folded into the price. 

Question Three: What did the parties say to each other? 

A supplier email promising a credit if the duties went away can decide a case on its own.

Contact a Commercial Litigation Attorney Before The Demand Letter Arrives

In terms of practice pointers, both sides should act now. Importers should review their largest customer relationships before filing for a refund, announcing plans for the money or offering credits, since each of those steps can end up as evidence. Declining the refund is not safe harbor. Customers can sue either way, and shareholders may ask why money was left unclaimed. Buyers should flag every invoice that carried a tariff charge, total the amounts by supplier, and send a short written request asking whether the supplier has claimed a refund and how it plans to share it. 

For importers, a refund can arrive with a claim attached, while for business buyers, it may be money they are owed but will never see unless they ask for it. The ultimate takeaway is that both sides should pull their contracts, invoices and correspondence now and decide where they stand, well before the first demand letter or complaint arrives. 

 
About Rome LLP

Rome LLP is a boutique law firm in Los Angeles offering a spectrum of legal services to businesses facing complex legal challenges. Our experienced team of attorneys is dedicated to securing excellent results on behalf of clients across industries in a wide range of matters at an international level, from business and commercial litigation, domain name litigation, IP and trade secrets, FTC investigations and enforcement defense, payment processing and fintech disputes, as well as matters involving cryptocurrency and blockchain projects. For more information, visit the Rome LLP website.

SHARE THIS:

Related News

FTC’s $12 Million Humboldt Settlement Is a Warning to ISOs

Reading Time: 3 minutesThe Federal Trade Commission announced a $12 million settlement on September 8, 2026 with 5967 Ventures LLC, doing business as Humboldt Merchant Services. The FTC alleges the payment processor opened and serviced accounts for more than 1,000 shell companies that

Read More »